“The assumption that lies at the basis of all the objections… is that the universe is a universe of chance…. We would ask whether the assumption of a universe of chance can furnish a foundation for a universal law of contradiction. Our opponents take for granted that they are applying to our concepts nothing but a law of contradiction that is recognized as universally valid by any one who is rational. So we would now ask whether there is any such law of contradiction that is universally valid if the universe is a universe of chance. The answer is simple. If the universe is a universe of chance, there is no law of contradiction at all. In such a universe everyone is master to himself. In such a universe there could be nothing but a Babel of confusion; no one would be able to speak with his neighbor. Accordingly we hold it to be the best proof of the truth of our position that our opponents are able to make objections to it that seem to have some sort of reason. This fact is the best proof that the universe is not a universe of chance.”
(Cornelius Van Til, Foundations of Christian Education, 94)